The Benefits of Hiring Individuals with Criminal Records

The Benefits of Hiring Individuals with Criminal Records: A Balanced Perspective

The concept of Fair Chance Hiring has gained significant momentum in recent years, particularly as more businesses and lawmakers recognize the economic and social benefits of integrating individuals with criminal records into the workforce. With nearly 80 million people in the U.S. having an arrest or conviction record, this represents a substantial and often untapped labor pool​. However, while there are clear advantages, it is important to consider both the benefits and the realistic concerns surrounding this practice.

The Business Case for Fair Chance Hiring

One of the strongest arguments for Fair Chance Hiring is the expansion of the talent pool. According to the Colorado Department of Corrections, about 10,000 individuals are released from prison annually in Colorado alone​. Nationally, individuals with criminal records face an unemployment rate of 27%, far higher than the general population​. Yet, numerous studies have shown that employees with conviction histories perform just as well, if not better, than their counterparts without records.

A military study involving over 1.3 million enlistees found that those with conviction records were promoted more quickly and reached higher ranks than their peers. Additionally, studies in sectors such as call centers show that employees with conviction histories have longer tenures and lower turnover rates. These findings underscore the reliability and retention advantages of hiring individuals with records, which can lead to savings of up to $1,000 per position annually for employers.

Addressing DEI (Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion)

Fair Chance Hiring also plays a vital role in promoting DEI. People of color are disproportionately impacted by the criminal justice system, with Black individuals being incarcerated at five times the rate of white individuals​. This imbalance extends into the labor market, where Black job seekers with a conviction history are penalized more severely than their white counterparts, making it twice as hard for them to find employment. Fair Chance Hiring addresses these disparities and aligns with the broader mission of many companies to improve diversity and inclusion within their workforce​.

Tax Credits and Financial Incentives

Employers who engage in Fair Chance Hiring can benefit from various financial incentives, including the Work Opportunity Tax Credit (WOTC). This federal program offers tax credits to employers who hire individuals from certain target groups, including those with conviction records, potentially reducing a company’s federal tax liability by as much as $2,400 per eligible hire​. Additionally, programs like the Federal Bonding Program provide insurance coverage to employers, reducing the perceived risk of hiring individuals with criminal records​.

Mitigating Risks and Concerns

While the benefits are clear, employers understandably have concerns about potential risks, such as negligent hiring lawsuits or the possibility of recidivism. However, data indicates that such risks are often overstated. According to a study mentioned during a recent Fair Chance Hiring presentation, only 3% of all lawsuits involve claims of negligent hiring, and less than 1% result in a company being found liable​.

Moreover, research shows that individuals with conviction records who find stable employment are significantly less likely to reoffend. In fact, the likelihood of reoffending is reduced by approximately 60% when individuals are employed, highlighting the social benefits of Fair Chance Hiring. Employers can also mitigate risks through individualized assessments of candidates, considering both the nature of their conviction and the relevance to the job. Many states, including Colorado, offer statutory protections for employers who hire individuals whose criminal records do not relate directly to their job responsibilities​.

Building a Supportive Framework for Success

For Fair Chance Hiring to be successful, businesses need to create a supportive environment. This starts with eliminating inquiries about conviction records early in the hiring process, in line with "ban the box" laws that prevent employers from asking about criminal records during initial applications. Employers are encouraged to adopt Fair Chance Hiring policies, develop individualized assessment templates, and create structured interview processes that focus on skills rather than background​.

As Robert Blume, a partner at Gibson Dunn, noted, “Incarcerated individuals often have nothing else to do but learn.” Many people leaving the prison system have earned certificates or skills that can make them valuable assets to companies, but these credentials are often overlooked due to outdated perceptions​. By working with organizations and community programs, businesses can ensure that candidates are prepared to succeed in their roles, benefitting both the employee and the employer.

Balancing Opportunities with Realistic Cautions

Despite the positive outcomes, it’s important to maintain a balanced perspective. Not every individual with a criminal record will be a perfect fit for every role, and employers should approach Fair Chance Hiring with a thoughtful, case-by-case approach. As Jessica Brown of Gibson Dunn highlighted during the Fair Chance Hiring event, “Employers can experience significant risk without a thoughtful Fair Chance Hiring program.” Neglecting to conduct individualized assessments or failing to understand legal requirements could expose employers to potential liability​.

Companies should also be mindful of insurance coverage limitations and work closely with their brokers to ensure that they are adequately covered when hiring individuals with criminal records. Leveraging bonding programs and educating insurers about the company’s hiring practices can help mitigate these risks.

Conclusion

Fair Chance Hiring offers a win-win scenario for businesses and society at large. It allows companies to tap into a largely overlooked labor pool, improve retention, and contribute to reducing recidivism. However, employers must proceed thoughtfully, implementing the necessary safeguards and support systems to ensure both the success of the hire and the protection of their business. By doing so, they can be agents of change, promoting inclusivity and offering second chances to individuals who need them the most.

If you would like to learn more about Fair Chance Hiring, contact HR BRanches today to get your hands on some fantastic resources!